Melissa Leo did not win. This was not a surprise (it was Winslet's year and everyone knew it), but by the time it happened I felt like it was for the best, because as awesome as I think Melissa Leo is, I did not necessarily want to see her dress again.

The color suits you (-ish), I support the covering o' the shoulders, and I like the full-but-not-crinoline skirt - but did you look at this dress before you left the house? It's four sizes too big in the middle! Also, it's from 1986, but if you didn't notice the sizing I figure it's pointless to explain eras of fashion, since judging from this picture from the Independent Spirit Awards, you seem to be fashion-era-impaired:

By the way, who told you to blow out your hair? Because that person is your enemy.
The good news is, your jewelry rocks my socks:

"Yes, hi, I'd like something to set off my hair - green glass? Lovely, I'll take it. And maybe a matching neckla - IS THAT A SPIDER? GIVE IT TO ME."
The jewelry singlehandedly takes you over to Awesome.
There was actually a lot of Awesome on the red carpet last night, one way or another!
Marisa Tomei found a stunner. It has approximately 543,292 pleats, and looks amazing. I did spend most of Mickey Rourke's cutaways trying to figure out how she sat down, but that's my issue, not hers.

I did not love the cut of Freida Pinto's dress - I loved the color, LOVED the embroidery, but something about the proportions of the neckline vs. that one sleeve is just weird. Also, on a several-thousand-dollar dress, I would like my sheer sleeve to have the seam under the arm and not right along the top, okay, dress people? That's just sloppy.
The good news: I'm pretty sure she wins the This is How to do Subtle Fancy Makeup Award:

(That dress costs thousands of dollars! FIX THE SEAM.)
Sophia Loren wakes up every morning and thinks, "I am going to be FABULOUS today." Or, she wakes up and thinks, "Today I wish to look as though I am in the midst of being consumed alive by an enormous chiffon cephalopod!" Both of these things apply here.

Tilda Swinton is just better than you, all right? We all know it. It's okay.

Tina Fey, who (with Steve Martin) delivered the only three watchable minutes of the show, picked the perfect dress for her, in that she is clearly wearing it like it's a tee shirt, which is how you sell formalwear. Ask any underage hostage in the Bryant Park tents, they'll tell you the same thing.

Marion Cotillard, who won last year in a dress so fitted you could see her lungs and got hugged by eight million people, decided this year she was going to go as Odile the Evil Swan, because when your dress is ten feet in diameter no gross people can try to hug you. I approve.

Rachel Weisz also stopped by, for one of the afterparties, to remind you that she is the best choice for Catwoman in the third Batman movie, and by "you" I mean Christopher Nolan.

However, the best dress of the night hardly got photographed, and I had to turn to Getty's dutiful backstage pictures to get any evidence of it. Megan Mylan, who won for short-form documentary, showed up in one of the most beautiful dresses I've ever seen, and by far the best dress that walked the carpet last night:

It's got a boatneck front, and the straps turn into two teardrop cowls, lined in cream, that meet in a V at the back, with a small train.
Another angle, that shows the drape of the cowls:

If you have noticed a correlation between this dress and my ideal prom dress, give yourself a cookie.
However, as lovely as it is, it's still second-best. No dress has ever come close to deposing what I consider the Best Oscar Dress of All Time:

I am serious. This dress is a feat of engineering, it's memorable, and it perfectly encapsulates the personality of the person who wore it. It's not a dress with a Bjork in it: it's Bjork in a dress. Also, it's shaped like a giant swan. Best Oscar dress ever. I'll throw down about it.
February 23 2009, 15:53:10 UTC 3 years ago
I LOVED the Evile Odile Dress. Wannnnnt.
February 23 2009, 15:58:45 UTC 3 years ago
3 years ago
3 years ago
3 years ago
February 23 2009, 15:57:00 UTC 3 years ago
February 23 2009, 16:00:35 UTC 3 years ago
3 years ago
3 years ago
February 23 2009, 15:59:48 UTC 3 years ago
I miss the '70s.
February 23 2009, 16:01:51 UTC 3 years ago
3 years ago
3 years ago
3 years ago
3 years ago
3 years ago
1 year ago
February 23 2009, 16:26:23 UTC 3 years ago
February 23 2009, 16:56:37 UTC 3 years ago
I would like to see Miley's dress on someone with personality; I feel like that dress needs to be worn by someone awesome, and Miley Cyrus is Not It.
February 23 2009, 16:33:22 UTC 3 years ago
Tilda is just uber.
February 23 2009, 16:58:16 UTC 3 years ago
Tilda is so amazing. I'm glad she's FINALLY come into her own - I still don't understand why she hasn't been famous since Orlando, and why it took some random Narnia movie to make her famous.
February 23 2009, 16:41:04 UTC 3 years ago
necklaceneck-drapery was unfortunate. Thoughts on either of those get-ups?February 23 2009, 17:01:57 UTC 3 years ago
I did not like Amy's dress because I felt like the center fabric-scoop took away from the amazing piping and made it look like she tucked up part of her dress to cover a coffee stain. I also did not like the necklace with the piping - too many detail elements - and the color of the dress leeched off the necklace and really detracted from the impact of each. However, I respect her trying something new. Just...not this one.
3 years ago
3 years ago
February 23 2009, 17:40:00 UTC 3 years ago
THANK YOU I HAVE ALWAYS TRIED TO UPHOLD THIS.
Upon first seeing that bronze dress my internal monologue became enirely "Woah, woah, WOAH" in a desperate attempt to make Ms Leo stop.
I love your dress write-ups. I also love what you said about the Cyrus dress. And you know, the ingenue in question knows it. The look on her face says she is hostage to her own formal wear.
February 23 2009, 18:00:58 UTC 3 years ago
3 years ago
1 year ago
February 23 2009, 18:04:15 UTC 3 years ago
February 23 2009, 18:20:39 UTC 3 years ago
February 23 2009, 18:46:39 UTC 3 years ago
I felt sorry for Miley Cyrus's dress. It could have done much better in life, if it'd had the right opportunities. Miley was that boyfriend who lures you with dreams and leaves you alone in a cheap motel the morning after robbing a gas station together.
Also, I have never forgotten Bjork's swan dress. I think that was when I first began paying attention to Oscars fashion. Because music, boring speeches, sparkly earrings, and then boom! is that a dead animal draped around her neck? For sheer fascination, no other dress has ever beaten it.
February 23 2009, 20:56:11 UTC 3 years ago
I am not kidding that the swan dress was the best ever! Amazing dress, perfectly suited to the person who wore it. Thumbs up.
February 24 2009, 00:47:09 UTC 3 years ago
February 24 2009, 06:02:02 UTC 3 years ago
3 years ago
February 24 2009, 04:37:34 UTC 3 years ago
February 24 2009, 06:02:56 UTC 3 years ago
I don't understand what makes someone think they should put their couture on Miley Cyrus. What tween audience is supposed to shell out for similar gowns, exactly?
February 24 2009, 14:20:59 UTC 3 years ago
February 27 2009, 21:04:02 UTC 3 years ago
February 27 2009, 19:09:44 UTC 3 years ago
Megan Mylan's Red Oscar Dress
Our daughter accepted the Oscar wearing a dress designed by her grandmother, Julia Mylan, when she was a fashion illustration student at the Pratt Institute in New York City in the 1930s. Julia was a movie fan and she and Megan had a pact that should Megan ever be nominated, she'd wear her design.In just three weeks time designer — Darlene De Andrande
of New York City completed the dress (imagining the front).
Over the past 15 years I have used Julia's drawings in advertisements for my consignment store in Dallas and after Julia died late last year at 95, we redesigned our website using them. The red dress is on our homepage at www.clothescircuit.com.
More about Megan's film at www.smilepinki.com
Proud Mom
February 27 2009, 21:55:38 UTC 3 years ago
Re: Megan Mylan's Red Oscar Dress
It's a beautiful dress, and an even more beautiful story! Please let her know she was the highlight of the ceremony for me.The sketch itself is lovely! Beautiful lines. (And I see that some of your jewelry selections from Clothes Circuit went up to the inauguration - a stylish family all around, then!)
3 years ago
3 years ago
1 year ago